When the CEO changes the rules of engagement also change

There is an uncomfortable truth about organisational leadership that we don’t always acknowledge: the rules of engagement can change overnight, even when the organisation itself appears unchanged.
The strategy may be the same. The values are still displayed on the walls. The organisational chart may have changed very little. Yet the arrival of a new CEO can fundamentally alter how decisions are made, how disagreement is received, whose opinions carry weight and what constitutes acceptable behaviour.
I have experienced leadership transitions from several perspectives during my career, both within large multinational organisations and in other leadership environments. Some have been positive, bringing renewed energy, clarity and a welcome willingness to challenge established thinking. Others have been considerably more difficult.
What I have come to appreciate is that a change of CEO is rarely just a change of leader. It is often a renegotiation of the unwritten rules by which the organisation operates. And for those who have spent years building their careers, relationships and credibility within an organisation, that can be deeply unsettling.
The organisation you knew may no longer exist
One of the most challenging aspects of a leadership transition is that the organisation can look remarkably familiar while feeling entirely different. The people are largely the same. The meetings continue. The projects remain. Yet something has shifted.
Under one leader, constructive disagreement might have been actively encouraged. Challenging an assumption was seen as evidence of engagement and intellectual honesty. Under another, the same behaviour may be interpreted as resistance, negativity or a failure to support the direction of travel.
Similarly, a leader who previously valued independence and initiative may be replaced by someone who expects closer consultation, greater visibility and more explicit alignment before decisions are taken.
Neither approach is necessarily wrong. Leadership styles differ, and a new CEO has every right to establish expectations appropriate to the organisation’s circumstances. The difficulty arises when these expectations remain unspoken.
People continue operating according to the rules they have learned, only to discover that those rules no longer apply. What was previously regarded as a strength can suddenly become a liability.
When your strengths become your vulnerabilities
This is an aspect of leadership transitions that I have reflected on considerably. Throughout a career, we develop a particular way of operating. We learn which behaviours are valued, how to influence decisions and when to challenge. Over time, these behaviours become part of our professional identity.
For me, one of the most important principles has always been the willingness to question decisions when I believe there is a legitimate concern, particularly where clinical evidence, patient safety or professional integrity are involved.
My background in medicine has undoubtedly shaped this approach. Clinical practice teaches you that hierarchy does not make someone infallible. A senior colleague can be mistaken, and sometimes the most important contribution you can make is to ask an uncomfortable question.
Indeed, in medicine, the consequences of failing to challenge can be substantial.
I have carried that philosophy into corporate leadership. I believe organisations make better decisions when experienced people are encouraged to question assumptions, examine evidence and express disagreement respectfully. But I have also learned that the willingness to challenge is not universally interpreted as a virtue.
In some leadership cultures, challenge is welcomed as a contribution to better decision-making. In others, it can be perceived as questioning authority. The same behaviour, motivated by the same professional principles, can produce very different reactions depending on who occupies the most senior position. That is a difficult lesson, particularly when the behaviour in question is something you regard as fundamental to your integrity.
It forces an uncomfortable question: how much should we adapt our behaviour to accommodate a new leader, and at what point does adaptation become a compromise of our principles? I don’t think there is a simple answer.
The invisible redistribution of power
Leadership transitions also change the informal networks through which organisations operate. Every organisation has a formal structure, but it also has an informal one. There are people whose judgement is trusted, individuals who can influence decisions without holding the most senior titles, and relationships built through years of shared experience. A new CEO inevitably changes that landscape. Some individuals find themselves closer to the centre of decision-making. Others, sometimes through no failing of their own, discover that their influence has diminished.
The uncomfortable reality is that professional credibility is not always transferable between leadership regimes. You may have spent years earning the confidence of one senior leader, only to discover that their successor places greater value on different qualities, relationships or priorities.
I have seen how destabilising this can be, particularly for experienced executives who have become accustomed to having a voice. It can be tempting to interpret the change personally. To assume that diminished influence reflects diminished competence, or that a previously valued contribution has somehow become less worthwhile. But the redistribution of influence often says as much about the new leader’s preferences and priorities as it does about the individuals affected. Recognising this doesn’t necessarily make the experience easier. It does, however, help us interpret it more accurately.
The danger of confusing loyalty with agreement
One of the most revealing characteristics of any leadership culture is how it responds to disagreement. I have worked with leaders who were comfortable being challenged. They recognised that loyalty to the organisation did not require unquestioning agreement with every decision. In fact, they understood that the willingness to express a different view could be an important demonstration of commitment.
I have also encountered environments in which the distinction between loyalty and agreement became less clear.
When that happens, the consequences can extend far beyond individual relationships.
People begin to modify what they say. Concerns are raised privately rather than openly. Meetings become exercises in demonstrating alignment rather than examining difficult questions.
Eventually, leaders may find themselves surrounded by people who appear to agree with them, not because everyone shares their judgement, but because disagreement has become professionally uncomfortable. This is particularly dangerous in organisations dealing with complex technical, scientific or clinical decisions.
An organisation in which people are reluctant to challenge its most senior leaders is not necessarily aligned. It may simply have learned to remain silent.
I think this is one of the greatest responsibilities of a CEO: creating an environment in which people can disagree without fearing that disagreement will be interpreted as disloyalty. Of course, challenge also carries responsibilities. It should be constructive, proportionate and grounded in evidence. There comes a point when decisions must be made and teams need to move forward. But there is an important difference between expecting people to support an agreed decision and expecting them never to question it. Good leaders understand that distinction.
The emotional cost of organisational change
We often discuss leadership transitions in strategic or operational terms. We talk about restructuring, priorities, culture and performance. What we discuss less frequently is their emotional impact on experienced leaders. There is an assumption that senior executives should be sufficiently resilient to accommodate changes in leadership without becoming personally affected. I think that assumption is unrealistic.
People invest enormous amounts of themselves in their professional lives. They develop relationships, build teams, champion initiatives and take pride in what they have achieved. When a leadership transition changes their place within an organisation, the impact can go beyond professional disappointment. It can challenge their sense of belonging, their confidence and even their understanding of their own effectiveness.
I have reflected on this in my own career. There have been occasions when I have found myself questioning whether I had misjudged a situation, whether I should have approached a conversation differently, or whether my expectations of leadership were simply unrealistic. Those are not always comfortable reflections.
It is easy, particularly when relationships become strained, to construct a narrative in which we are entirely right and the other person is entirely wrong. Experience has taught me to be suspicious of such narratives.
There are usually aspects of our own behaviour worth examining, even when we believe our underlying position is justified.
I have found it helpful to distinguish between three questions:
Was my concern legitimate?
Was the way I expressed it effective?
Was the environment receptive to hearing it?
These are related questions, but they are not the same.
A legitimate concern can be communicated badly. A well-communicated concern can still be unwelcome. And sometimes both the concern and its expression are entirely reasonable, but the organisational culture has little appetite for challenge. Understanding the difference is essential if we are to learn from difficult experiences without unnecessarily undermining our confidence.
Adaptability is not the same as surrender
When a new CEO arrives, some adaptation is inevitable. Indeed, an unwillingness to adapt can itself become a leadership weakness. A new leader deserves the opportunity to establish priorities, reshape relationships and bring their own approach to the organisation.
The question is not whether we should adapt, but how. I have increasingly come to think of this in terms of distinguishing between our preferences and our principles.
Preferences concern how we like to work: our communication style, the level of autonomy we enjoy, the way decisions are discussed and how frequently we engage with senior colleagues. These are often negotiable.
Principles are different. For me, they include professional integrity, honesty, respect for others and a commitment to making decisions based on sound evidence.
Those are not things I would want to abandon simply because a new leader prefers a different approach.
The challenge is learning to be flexible about the former without compromising the latter. That may mean changing how we communicate disagreement, choosing our moments more carefully, investing more deliberately in relationships or recognising that not every difference of opinion warrants a confrontation. But it should not mean suppressing legitimate concerns simply to preserve our standing.
The most effective leaders learn to adapt their methods without losing their moral compass.
What I would do differently
One of the benefits of experience is that it gives us the opportunity to revisit situations with greater perspective. If I were approaching a significant leadership transition again, there are several things I would pay closer attention to.
Firstly, I would spend more time understanding the new leader before assuming that the relationship would operate according to familiar conventions.
What matters most to them? How do they prefer to receive difficult information? What does trust look like from their perspective? How do they distinguish constructive challenge from resistance? I would be more deliberate about establishing expectations early. Many leadership conflicts develop not because people fundamentally disagree about objectives, but because they hold different assumptions about how those objectives should be pursued. I would pay closer attention to the informal signals of cultural change.
What happens when someone disagrees in a meeting? Who is invited into important conversations? Are difficult questions explored or closed down? Do people speak differently in private from how they speak in public? These observations can tell us far more about an emerging leadership culture than any formal statement of organisational values.
Finally, I would remind myself that my professional worth is not determined by the opinion of one individual, however senior. That is perhaps easier to write than to practise. When we have invested heavily in our careers, it is remarkably easy to allow the approval or disapproval of a senior leader to influence how we see ourselves. But leadership maturity requires a degree of independence from external validation.
We should be willing to listen, learn and change. We should also retain the confidence to recognise when a difficult relationship reflects a mismatch of expectations or values rather than a fundamental failure of competence.
Where executive coaching can help
This is one of the areas where I believe executive coaching can be particularly valuable.
When a leadership transition becomes difficult, it can be surprisingly hard to think clearly about what is happening.
Emotions become entangled with professional judgement. We replay conversations, anticipate conflict and sometimes become so focused on the behaviour of others that we lose sight of the choices available to us.
A good coaching relationship provides a confidential space to examine those choices. Not simply to validate our frustrations, but to challenge our assumptions. What evidence do we have for our interpretation of events? What might the situation look like from the other person’s perspective? Which aspects are within our control? What are we prepared to compromise on, and what genuinely matters to us?
Sometimes the outcome is a better working relationship.
Sometimes it is a change in how we approach difficult conversations.
And occasionally, it is the recognition that an environment no longer allows us to contribute in a way that is consistent with our values.
Coaching cannot remove the uncertainty of organisational change. It can, however, help leaders respond to that uncertainty with greater clarity and intention.
A final reflection
I have come to believe that leadership transitions reveal as much about the culture of an organisation as they do about the individuals involved. A change of CEO can create extraordinary opportunities. It can challenge complacency, introduce fresh thinking and revitalise an organisation that has become too comfortable with its established ways of working. But it can also expose how dependent organisational culture is on the personality and preferences of the person at the top.
For those navigating such transitions, the challenge is to remain open to change without losing sight of who they are.
To be adaptable without becoming compliant.
To remain willing to challenge without becoming unnecessarily confrontational.
To recognise that sometimes the rules of engagement have changed, even when nobody has formally announced it.
Perhaps the most important question we can ask ourselves is this:
Am I resisting this change because it challenges my habits and preferences, or because it asks me to compromise something I genuinely believe matters?
The answer may tell us more about our next step than anything written in the new organisational strategy.
Leadership transitions can challenge even the most experienced executives. At Blackridge Leadership, I work with senior leaders navigating organisational change, difficult professional relationships and the complexities of executive decision-making.
If you’re facing a leadership challenge and would value a confidential conversation, you can learn more about my executive coaching approach at Blackridge Leadership.






Comments