The Loneliness of Senior Leadership: Why the Higher You Rise, the Less People Tell You
Updated: Nov 7

One of the more uncomfortable things I’ve learned during my career is that the more senior you become, the less likely people are to tell you what they really think. It’s a curious contradiction. You spend years developing your experience, building relationships and earning the trust of colleagues. Eventually, you find yourself in a position where your judgement carries considerable weight. Yet, just when you might reasonably expect to have access to the best information and the most honest advice, something begins to change. People become more careful around you.
They choose their words differently, become less inclined to challenge your opinions, and difficult conversations are postponed, softened or occasionally avoided altogether. You may find yourself surrounded by capable, intelligent people who are perfectly willing to agree with you, but rather less willing to tell you that you’re wrong. I don’t think this happens because people are necessarily dishonest. Most aren’t. I think it happens because seniority changes relationships, often in ways that neither party fully appreciates. Perhaps the most troubling aspect is that the person least likely to recognise this change is the leader themselves.
When I first began to notice
Looking back, I can see how my understanding of leadership changed as my responsibilities increased. In the Emergency Department, hierarchy certainly existed, but there was also an immediacy to our work that encouraged a degree of openness. If a patient was deteriorating, it mattered very little whether the person recognising it was a consultant, a junior doctor or an experienced nurse. What mattered was that someone spoke up.
Of course, clinical hierarchies could be intimidating, and I would be naive to suggest that everyone always felt comfortable challenging a senior colleague. They didn’t, but the nature of emergency medicine meant that we were frequently confronted by situations in which nobody had the luxury of pretending that everything was fine. A patient either improved or deteriorated. A treatment worked or it didn’t. Sometimes we got things wrong, and the consequences were immediately apparent. There was something rather grounding about that.
As I moved into corporate roles, I began to appreciate that leadership operated according to a different set of rules. The consequences of decisions were often less immediate. Relationships were more complicated. Organisational politics played a greater role, and the distinction between what people thought and what they were prepared to say became increasingly important. I also began to recognise something about myself. Like most people, I enjoyed being told that I had made a good decision. I appreciated colleagues agreeing with my proposals. It was reassuring to feel that the people around me supported my judgement, but reassurance and good advice are not necessarily the same thing, and agreement, however sincerely expressed, is not always evidence that you’re right.
The subtle ways people stop leaders telling you the truth
I don’t believe that most leaders suddenly find themselves surrounded by people who deliberately conceal information. The process is usually much more subtle. A colleague might disagree with a proposal but decide that the issue isn’t sufficiently important to justify an argument. Someone else might have concerns about a strategy but assume that the senior leadership team has information they haven’t seen. A junior member of staff might recognise a problem but worry that raising it will make them appear negative or difficult. Individually, these decisions are understandable, but collectively they can become dangerous.
I’ve observed situations where a senior leader has presented an idea to a room full of experienced professionals and received almost universal agreement. Afterwards, in smaller conversations, it becomes apparent that several people had significant reservations. Why didn’t they say anything? Sometimes it was because they didn’t believe their concerns would change the outcome. Sometimes they wanted to preserve a relationship. Occasionally, they were simply reluctant to challenge someone who had influence over their career. In other cases, I suspect they were waiting for somebody else to speak first.
What I find particularly interesting is that leaders can inadvertently encourage this behaviour without ever intending to. A dismissive comment during a meeting, an impatient response to a difficult question, or a tendency to defend a proposal rather than explore its weaknesses may seem insignificant at the time, but people remember these things. Over time, they learn which conversations are welcome and which are best avoided. Eventually, the leader may begin to believe that the absence of disagreement represents genuine consensus, when in reality it may simply mean that people have stopped trying.
The loneliness nobody talks about
When we discuss loneliness in leadership, we often imagine a senior executive sitting alone in an office, burdened by decisions that nobody else can make. There is some truth in that image, but I think it misses something more important. Leadership loneliness isn’t necessarily about being physically alone. In fact, senior leaders are often surrounded by people. Their diaries are full, their phones rarely stop ringing, and much of their working life is spent in meetings. The loneliness comes from having fewer relationships in which they can be completely candid.
There are things you cannot easily discuss with your direct reports. You may be worried about the direction of the organisation, but expressing those concerns too openly could undermine confidence. You may be struggling with a difficult relationship with your own manager, but discussing it with your team places them in an uncomfortable position. You might be uncertain about a decision, yet feel that everyone expects you to have the answer. There are occasions when you simply need to admit that you don’t know what to do, but finding someone with whom you can have that conversation isn’t always straightforward.
I’ve experienced that tension myself. There have been times during my career when I’ve been expected to provide direction and reassurance while privately wrestling with uncertainty. I’ve learned that it is possible to appear entirely confident in a meeting and then spend the journey home questioning whether you’ve made the right decision. I suspect many senior leaders would recognise that experience. What makes it difficult is not necessarily the uncertainty itself. Most experienced leaders understand that uncertainty is unavoidable. It is the feeling that there are fewer people with whom you can safely explore it.
The problem with being the most senior person in the room
One of the privileges of senior leadership is that people listen to you. One of its dangers is that people listen to you. I have become increasingly conscious of how much influence a senior leader can exert simply by expressing an opinion. Imagine a meeting in which a team is considering several possible approaches to a difficult problem. The senior leader speaks early and indicates a preference. Sometimes the discussion continues openly, alternatives are explored, assumptions challenged and the eventual decision is better for it, but sometimes the atmosphere changes.
People begin to organise their contributions around the leader’s preference. Arguments supporting the proposed approach receive more attention, while reservations are expressed cautiously, if at all. Before long, the meeting appears to have reached a consensus, yet that consensus may have been shaped less by the strength of the argument than by the authority of the person who made it. I’ve seen this happen all too often, and I have no doubt that I’ve contributed to it myself. That is an uncomfortable admission, but I think it’s an important one.
We often talk about the responsibility of employees to speak up. We spend considerable time encouraging openness, psychological safety and constructive challenge, but I wonder whether we spend enough time considering the responsibility of senior leaders to make disagreement genuinely possible. It is easy to say that your door is always open. It is rather harder to ensure that people feel comfortable walking through it with something you don’t want to hear.
Experience can become a disadvantage
There is another aspect of senior leadership that I’ve come to reflect on more as I’ve grown older. Experience is enormously valuable. It allows us to recognise patterns, anticipate problems and make decisions without having to analyse every possible outcome from first principles. In medicine, that experience could be invaluable. You develop an instinct for when a patient is seriously unwell, sometimes before the observations or investigations provide a clear explanation.
Experience has limitations, however. The same pattern recognition that allows us to make good decisions quickly can also encourage us to reach conclusions prematurely. We begin to believe that because we’ve encountered something similar before, we understand what is happening now. When we become sufficiently senior, there may be fewer people willing to question that assumption. I have occasionally found myself becoming attached to an interpretation of events because it fitted with my previous experience. Only later, after hearing another perspective, have I recognised that I was overlooking something important.
The difficulty is that experience can make us more confident at precisely the moment when we should be more curious. I increasingly think that one of the marks of mature leadership is the ability to distinguish between having confidence in your judgement and being certain that your judgement is correct. They are not the same thing.
What I’ve observed in others in leadership
Over the years, I’ve worked with some exceptionally capable senior leaders. The best have not necessarily been the most charismatic, the most forceful or even the most obviously confident. Often, they have been the people who seemed genuinely interested in what others thought. They asked questions and waited for the answers. They were prepared to change their minds and could acknowledge uncertainty without appearing overwhelmed by it. Perhaps most importantly, they didn’t seem to regard disagreement as a personal challenge.
I’ve also observed the opposite. Leaders who were undoubtedly intelligent and experienced but who gradually became less receptive to alternative views. Sometimes this appeared to arise from confidence in their own abilities. Sometimes it seemed to reflect the pressure they were under. The more difficult their circumstances became, the more tightly they held on to their own interpretation of events. I can understand that response. When you’re responsible for a large organisation, significant budgets or decisions affecting people’s livelihoods, uncertainty can feel uncomfortable. Having a clear position provides reassurance, both to yourself and to others.
There is a difference, however, between providing direction and becoming unwilling to reconsider it. The leaders I’ve admired most have managed to do both: provide clarity while remaining open to the possibility that they might be wrong. I don’t think that’s easy, and I certainly wouldn’t claim to have mastered it myself.
Why senior leaders need people who have nothing to gain from agreeing with them
As my career has developed, I’ve become increasingly convinced that senior leaders need relationships in which they can speak openly without having to manage the consequences of every word. That might be a trusted colleague, an experienced mentor, a longstanding friend or someone outside the organisation entirely. The important thing is that the relationship allows for honesty rather than simply reassurance. Someone who is willing to ask why you believe what you believe, challenge your assumptions and help you recognise the things you may be avoiding.
There is something particularly valuable about speaking to someone who has no stake in the organisational politics surrounding a decision. They don’t need your approval, aren’t competing for promotion and don’t have to worry about how their response might affect their next performance review. They can simply tell you what they think.
This is one of the reasons I’ve become interested in executive coaching. Not because I believe coaches possess some special insight into every leadership problem, and certainly not because I think coaching can replace experience, judgement or the responsibility that comes with senior leadership. Rather, I think a good coaching relationship can provide something that becomes increasingly difficult to find as careers progress: a confidential space in which someone can think aloud, acknowledge uncertainty and have their assumptions challenged without needing to maintain the appearance of having everything under control.
Coaching isn’t the only answer, however. Sometimes what a leader needs is a colleague who will disagree with them. Sometimes it is a friend who knows them well enough to recognise when they’re becoming unreasonable. Sometimes it is simply the humility to listen properly to the people already around them. The essential ingredient is not the professional title of the person offering support, but the quality and honesty of the conversation.
What I would tell my younger self
If I could offer some advice to the younger version of myself, particularly as I began moving into more senior leadership positions, I think it would be this. Don’t confuse agreement with respect. Don’t assume that silence means people have no concerns, and don’t become so invested in appearing confident that you lose the ability to admit uncertainty.
I would also encourage myself to pay closer attention to the people who disagreed with me. Not because they were necessarily right, but because they were often providing something more valuable than another expression of support. They were giving me an opportunity to examine my thinking. I would remind myself that the way I responded to challenge mattered enormously. If somebody raised an uncomfortable issue, my reaction would influence whether they felt able to do so again.
I would probably tell myself to speak less in meetings. That last point has taken me rather longer to appreciate than I would like. There is a temptation, particularly when you’ve spent years acquiring expertise, to demonstrate that expertise whenever an opportunity arises, but sometimes the most useful contribution a senior leader can make is to ask a question and then remain quiet long enough for somebody else to answer it.
The paradox of senior leadership
The longer I’ve worked , the more I’ve come to recognise a paradox. As your authority increases, your access to honest feedback can diminish. As your experience grows, you may become more susceptible to trusting your own judgement. As the consequences of your decisions become more significant, you may find fewer people with whom you feel able to discuss your doubts.
None of this is inevitable, but I think it requires conscious effort to avoid. Senior leaders need to create environments where disagreement is welcomed rather than merely tolerated. They need to recognise the influence their position has on the behaviour of others and maintain relationships in which they can be challenged without feeling that their authority is being threatened. Perhaps most importantly, they need to accept that leadership does not require certainty. It requires judgement, integrity and a willingness to reconsider your position when the evidence changes.
I’ve spent much of my professional life working in environments where decisions matter, sometimes enormously. One of the things that experience has taught me is that nobody, however senior or experienced, has a monopoly on good judgement. The danger comes when the people around us begin to behave as though we do.
Perhaps that is the real loneliness of senior leadership. Not that there is nobody around to talk to, but that fewer people are willing to tell us what we most need to hear.
As a leader, how do you know whether the people around you are telling you what they really think? When was the last time someone challenged your judgement, and how did you respond?




Comments