top of page

Leadership: Why authority will only get you so far

Nov 2
9 min read
Contemplative board room

I’ve worked with teams in environments where decisions needed to be made quickly, sometimes under considerable pressure, and where the consequences of getting things wrong could be significant. I’ve also worked in large organisations where the challenges were less immediate, but where achieving anything meaningful depended on persuading people with different priorities, responsibilities and perspectives to work towards a common objective.


What I’ve come to appreciate is that there is an enormous difference between someone doing what you ask because they have to, and doing it because they genuinely want to. Both may produce the same immediate result, but the quality of the work, the initiative people show and their willingness to support you when things become difficult can be remarkably different.

So what determines whether people will actually follow your lead?


Authority Will Get You So Far

When you become a leader, you acquire a certain amount of formal authority. You can allocate responsibilities, establish priorities, make decisions and hold people accountable. Depending on your position, you may also influence their performance assessments, career progression and remuneration.


These are powerful mechanisms, and it would be naive to pretend otherwise. Most people understand the expectations associated with their employment, and the majority will make a reasonable effort to fulfil them.


However, formal authority has its limitations. It may ensure that somebody completes a task, but it cannot guarantee that they approach it with enthusiasm, creativity or commitment. It doesn’t necessarily encourage someone to identify problems before they arise, challenge a poor decision or go beyond what has been explicitly requested.

I suspect most experienced leaders have encountered situations where a team has done precisely what was asked of them, but somehow failed to achieve what was intended. The instructions were followed, the boxes were ticked, yet something important was missing.


There is a difference between compliance and commitment, and I think understanding that distinction is one of the most important lessons in leadership.


People Need to Believe You Know What You’re Doing

Competence matters. Perhaps more than we sometimes care to admit. People are much more likely to follow someone whose judgement they respect. They want to know that the person making decisions understands the situation, has considered the alternatives and is capable of navigating the consequences.


In clinical medicine, I saw this particularly clearly. When circumstances became difficult, teams naturally looked towards individuals who demonstrated sound judgement, experience and composure. Their influence wasn’t always determined by their position in the hierarchy. Sometimes the person everyone listened to was simply the person they trusted to make the right decision.


I’ve observed the same phenomenon in business. A leader who consistently demonstrates good judgement gradually earns something that cannot be conferred by a job title: credibility.


Interestingly, credibility doesn’t require you to know everything. In fact, I’ve found that leaders who pretend to have all the answers can undermine their own authority. Being able to acknowledge uncertainty, seek advice and change your mind when presented with better evidence can strengthen people’s confidence in you.

Competence isn’t about being infallible. It’s about demonstrating that your decisions deserve to be taken seriously.


Trust Changes the Nature of the Relationship

If competence makes people believe that you can lead them, trust helps determine whether they are willing to let you. Trust develops through experience. People observe whether you keep your promises, whether you treat colleagues fairly and whether your behaviour is consistent with what you say. They notice how you respond when things go wrong, particularly when someone has made an honest mistake. I’ve always thought that the way a leader behaves during difficult moments reveals far more about their character than how they behave when everything is going well.


Consider two leaders. Both ask their teams to undertake a demanding piece of work. One has a reputation for taking credit when things succeed and finding someone to blame when they fail. The other is known for recognising contributions, accepting responsibility and supporting colleagues when circumstances become difficult.


The request may be identical, but I would expect the response to be very different. When people trust you, they are more willing to accept uncertainty, tolerate temporary inconvenience and believe that your decisions are being made for legitimate reasons. Without trust, even reasonable requests can be interpreted with suspicion. The difficulty is that trust takes considerable time to establish and can be lost surprisingly quickly.


People Are More Committed When They Understand Why

One of the mistakes I’ve made during my career is assuming that because the reason for a decision is obvious to me, it must be equally obvious to everyone else. As leaders, we often have access to information that our teams don’t. We attend different meetings, hear different conversations and understand organisational pressures that may not be apparent to those responsible for delivering the work.


By the time we communicate a decision, we may have spent days or weeks considering it. For the person receiving the instruction, however, it may be the first they’ve heard of it. What seems like a perfectly logical request to us can therefore appear arbitrary, inconvenient or even unreasonable to someone else. I’ve become increasingly convinced that explaining the reasoning behind a decision is not an optional courtesy. It’s an important part of effective leadership.


People are more likely to commit to a course of action when they understand what we’re trying to achieve, why it matters and how their contribution fits into the wider picture. They may not agree with every aspect of the decision, but understanding the rationale makes it easier to support.


This becomes particularly important when we’re asking people to change something they’ve been doing successfully for years. Without a convincing explanation, change can feel like disruption for its own sake.


Being Liked Helps, but Being Respected Matters More

I think most of us would prefer to be liked by the people we work with. There is nothing wrong with that. Positive relationships make working life more enjoyable and often make difficult conversations easier.


However, I’ve seen leaders become so concerned about maintaining good relationships that they begin to avoid making unpopular decisions. They hesitate to challenge poor performance, tolerate behaviour they know is unacceptable or make commitments they cannot realistically fulfil. The irony is that this can eventually damage the very relationships they’re trying to protect.


People generally appreciate leaders who are approachable, considerate and interested in them as individuals, but they also need to know where they stand. They want consistency, fairness and a willingness to make difficult decisions when necessary.

I’ve come to believe that being respected is more important than being universally liked, although the two are certainly not mutually exclusive.


Respect develops when people see that you’re prepared to act according to your principles, even when doing so is uncomfortable. It also develops when you demonstrate that those principles apply equally to everyone, including yourself.


A leader who expects punctuality but routinely arrives late, or who demands accountability while avoiding responsibility for their own mistakes, will struggle to retain credibility. People pay considerably more attention to what we do than to what we say.


People Need to Feel That Their Contribution Matters

There’s another factor that I think is sometimes overlooked. People are more likely to engage with a request when they feel they have some ownership of the outcome. Being told exactly what to do, how to do it and when to do it can be appropriate in certain circumstances. In an emergency, for example, there may be little opportunity for consultation. Clear instructions and immediate action can be essential.


Most leadership situations, however, allow considerably more room for discussion.

When we involve people in developing a solution, listen to their concerns and give them appropriate freedom to determine how the work should be undertaken, we create a different relationship with the task. It becomes something they’re helping to achieve rather than something being imposed upon them.


This doesn’t mean every decision needs to be made by committee. Leadership still involves making choices, sometimes against the preferences of others. Nevertheless, there’s a considerable difference between asking for input because you genuinely value it and asking simply to create the appearance of consultation. People usually recognise the difference.


Fairness Is More Important Than We Think

Few things undermine a leader’s influence more quickly than the perception of unfairness. People notice who receives opportunities, whose mistakes are overlooked, whose opinions are taken seriously and who is expected to carry the greatest burden. They notice whether the rules change depending on who is involved.


I’ve seen situations where individuals were willing to accept difficult decisions, including decisions that disadvantaged them personally, because they believed the process had been fair. Conversely, seemingly minor inconsistencies can create lasting resentment when people believe they’re being treated differently without good reason.

Fairness doesn’t mean treating everyone identically. Individuals have different circumstances, capabilities and needs. It means being consistent in our principles, transparent where possible and prepared to explain our reasoning. A team that believes its leader is fair is much more likely to accept difficult decisions, even when those decisions aren’t particularly welcome.


Confidence Is Contagious, but So Is Anxiety

One of the more subtle influences on whether people follow a leader is the emotional tone they establish. I’ve noticed that teams are remarkably sensitive to the behaviour of the person leading them. When a leader appears anxious, indecisive or defensive, that uncertainty can spread. Equally, someone who remains composed, communicates clearly and demonstrates confidence in the team’s ability can have a stabilising effect. This is particularly apparent when circumstances become challenging.


People don’t necessarily expect their leader to be optimistic about everything. Indeed, misplaced optimism can be just as damaging as excessive pessimism. What they need is confidence that the situation is being approached thoughtfully and that there is a credible way forward. There is something reassuring about a leader who can acknowledge that a problem is serious without appearing overwhelmed by it.


I think this is one of the reasons emotional self-awareness is so important in leadership. We may believe we’re simply expressing our own frustration or concern, but our behaviour can influence the confidence and motivation of everyone around us.


You Have to Make It Possible for People to Succeed

Even when people trust their leader, understand the objective and genuinely want to deliver, they may still struggle to do what is asked. Sometimes the problem isn’t motivation at all. It’s capacity.


I’ve encountered situations where leaders have interpreted a lack of progress as resistance, when the underlying issue was that the team simply didn’t have sufficient time, resources or authority to complete the work. We can be remarkably good at adding priorities and rather less effective at removing them.


If everything is important, people are left to make their own decisions about what can realistically be achieved. The resulting disappointment is then sometimes interpreted as a failure of commitment. Effective leadership involves more than setting expectations. It requires us to create the conditions in which those expectations can reasonably be met.


That may mean removing obstacles, negotiating resources, clarifying competing priorities or accepting that something else will have to wait. I think leaders sometimes underestimate how much influence they gain simply by making it easier for their teams to do good work.


The Most Important Test Is What Happens When You’re Not There

Perhaps the clearest indication of genuine leadership influence is what happens when the leader is absent. Does the team continue to pursue the objective with the same commitment? Do people make sensible decisions, support one another and take responsibility for the outcome? Are they willing to raise concerns and challenge assumptions without waiting for permission?


Or does progress depend upon constant supervision, repeated instructions and the knowledge that someone is watching? The distinction tells us something important about the kind of leadership we’ve established. A team that only performs when its leader is present may be well controlled, but it isn’t necessarily well led.


Over time, I think the aim should be to create an environment where people understand the purpose of their work, have confidence in their own judgement and feel sufficiently trusted to take responsibility. There is a paradox here. The more effective we become at leading people, the less dependent they should become upon our immediate direction.


A Final Reflection

Looking back over my career, I can think of occasions when people followed my instructions because of the position I held, and others when they did so because they trusted my judgement and believed in what we were trying to achieve.


At the time, the distinction wasn’t always obvious. In both situations, the work was completed. It was often only later, when circumstances became more difficult or when people were required to act independently, that the difference became apparent.


I also recognise occasions when I could have done more to explain my reasoning, involve colleagues in decisions or understand the pressures they were facing. Like many aspects of leadership, these are lessons that become clearer with experience.

The question I find myself returning to is not simply whether people will do what I ask. It’s why they choose to do it.


Are they responding to my authority, or have I earned their confidence? Do they understand what we’re trying to achieve, or are they simply following instructions? Have I created an environment in which people feel trusted, supported and able to contribute, or one in which compliance is the safest option? Formal authority may give us the right to direct others, but it doesn’t automatically give us their commitment.


The real measure of leadership isn’t whether people do what we ask when we’re watching. It’s whether they believe enough in the purpose, the team and our leadership to do the right thing when we’re not.


What makes you willing to follow someone else’s leadership? Is it their expertise, their character, the way they treat you, or something else entirely? And as a leader, have you ever considered whether your team follows you because they have to, or because they want to?


I explore the realities of leadership, trust, decision-making and executive resilience through my work with Blackridge Leadership.

Comments


bottom of page