top of page

How Do You Know What the Right Decision Is?

Oct 27
7 min read
Leader at a crossroads, making a decision

One of the things I’ve learned during my career is that the more senior you become, the harder it can be to know whether you’re making the right decision. That might seem counterintuitive. Surely experience should make decision-making easier? After all, we spend years developing our knowledge, refining our judgement and learning from our mistakes. By the time we reach senior leadership positions, shouldn’t we be rather good at making decisions? I used to think so, but I’ve come to realise that experience doesn’t necessarily make decisions easier. Sometimes it simply gives you the confidence to admit you may not know what’s right. There’s an important difference between being confident in a decision and being certain that it’s the right one.


When decisions were matters of life and death

Before moving into corporate leadership, I spent more than twenty years working in emergency medicine. As a hospital consultant, I regularly made decisions that had potentially life-changing consequences. Some needed to be made within seconds. Others involved weighing considerable risks, often with incomplete information and little opportunity to seek advice. Looking back, something strikes me as rather strange. Despite the potential consequences, I often found those clinical decisions easier than some of the decisions I’ve subsequently faced in corporate leadership.


That isn’t because the clinical decisions were straightforward. They frequently weren’t. But medicine provides a framework within which decisions can be made. We have clinical evidence, established guidelines, physiological principles and years of training. We learn to recognise patterns, assess probabilities and balance competing risks. We also develop an understanding of when we need to act and when we have time to gather more information. Importantly, we understand that making the right clinical decision doesn’t guarantee a good outcome.

A patient can deteriorate despite receiving entirely appropriate treatment. Conversely, a patient may recover despite decisions that, with hindsight, were questionable. We don’t judge clinical decisions solely by their outcomes. We also consider whether they were reasonable given the information available at the time. Yet, curiously, we don’t always apply the same principle to leadership.


The problem with being right

In corporate leadership, decisions are often considerably less well defined. Should we invest in one project rather than another? Should we restructure a team? Is someone struggling because they’re in the wrong role, or because we haven’t given them the support they need? Should we challenge a decision made by someone more senior, knowing that doing so might damage an important relationship? These questions rarely have objectively correct answers.


Different stakeholders may have entirely legitimate but competing priorities. The consequences may not become apparent for months or even years. Unlike clinical medicine, there isn’t always an established body of evidence to guide us. I’ve sat in meetings where intelligent, experienced people have examined exactly the same information and reached entirely different conclusions. Sometimes I’ve been convinced that my interpretation was correct, only to discover that someone else had identified something important that I’d overlooked.


That can be uncomfortable, particularly when you’re accustomed to being the person people look to for answers. But I’ve increasingly come to believe that one of the dangers of senior leadership is confusing the strength of our conviction with the quality of our judgement. Feeling certain doesn’t necessarily mean we’re right. In fact, the more strongly we believe something, the more important it may be to challenge our own assumptions.

The British actor and comedian, Stephen Fry, said during the 2018 Munk Debate, quoting the philosopher Bertrand Russell, “One of the painful things about our time is that those who feel certainty are stupid, and those with any imagination and understanding are filled with doubt and indecision.” I think there is something particularly relevant about this observation for those of us in leadership. We tend to associate confidence and certainty with competence, yet the more we understand about a problem, the more aware we become of its complexity and the limitations of our own knowledge. Perhaps one of the marks of an experienced leader is not an increasing certainty that they are right, but a growing willingness to acknowledge that they might be wrong.


A good decision can have a bad outcome

I think this is one of the most important distinctions leaders need to understand. We have a natural tendency to judge decisions retrospectively. If a project succeeds, we congratulate ourselves on making the right decision. If it fails, we search for the mistakes that led us there. Outcomes are influenced by countless factors, many of which are beyond our control. A carefully considered decision, supported by good evidence and sound reasoning, can still produce a disappointing outcome. Equally, a poorly considered decision can succeed through good fortune.

The danger is that we confuse outcomes with decision quality. When things go well, we may become overconfident. When they go badly, we may become excessively cautious, even when our original reasoning was entirely defensible. I’ve found it helpful to ask a different question. Rather than asking, “Was that the right decision?” I try to ask, “Given what I knew at the time, was that a reasonable decision to make?” It’s a subtle distinction, but an important one. It shifts our attention away from judging ourselves through the lens of hindsight and towards examining the quality of our thinking.

Of course, this doesn’t absolve leaders of responsibility. We remain accountable for the consequences of our decisions, and we have an obligation to learn when things go wrong. However, accountability and hindsight are not the same thing.

When doing nothing feels safer

One of the most tempting responses to uncertainty is to delay. When faced with a difficult decision, there’s always the possibility that another meeting, another analysis or another conversation will provide the clarity I’m looking for. Sometimes that’s exactly what happens. Sometimes we’re simply postponing the uncomfortable moment when we have to commit ourselves to a course of action.


The difficulty is that inaction is rarely neutral. A struggling employee continues to struggle. An underperforming project consumes resources. An unresolved disagreement damages relationships. An opportunity disappears. By avoiding the risk of making the wrong decision, we may inadvertently make a worse one.


I’ve come to think that an important leadership skill is recognising when additional information is genuinely likely to improve a decision and when we’re simply seeking reassurance. There is a point at which further analysis stops being useful. Recognising that point requires judgement, and sometimes courage.


What happens when the evidence isn’t enough?

There are occasions when two options are equally defensible. Both have advantages, but both carry risks. Neither offers a clearly superior outcome. What do we do then? I think this is where our values become particularly important. When evidence cannot resolve a decision, we need another framework to guide us. What matters most to us? What principles are we unwilling to compromise? How do we balance the interests of the organisation with our responsibilities towards the people who work within it?


These aren’t always comfortable questions. For example, a decision that makes perfect financial sense may have significant consequences for individuals. Equally, protecting people from every difficult organisational decision may ultimately undermine the organisation’s ability to succeed. Leadership frequently involves navigating these competing responsibilities.


I don’t believe there is a simple formula that resolves such dilemmas, but I do believe that understanding our values helps us make decisions we can subsequently explain and defend, even when the outcomes are disappointing. Perhaps that’s an important test. Can I explain why I made this decision, not simply in terms of what I hoped to achieve, but in terms of the principles that guided me?


The danger of making decisions alone

As leaders become more senior, something interesting happens. People increasingly expect them to have answers. Colleagues bring problems rather than solutions. Teams look for direction. Senior executives expect recommendations rather than expressions of uncertainty. Gradually, leaders can begin to feel that admitting uncertainty is somehow a sign of weakness.


I think that’s a mistake. Some of the best leaders I’ve worked with have been remarkably comfortable saying, ‘I don’t know.’ Not because they lacked confidence or competence, but because they understood the limitations of their own knowledge. They were willing to seek alternative perspectives, invite disagreement and challenge their assumptions before committing themselves.


There is another difficulty. The more senior you become, the fewer people you may feel comfortable talking to openly. You may not be able to discuss sensitive decisions with your team. You may be reluctant to expose uncertainty to your manager. Colleagues who are directly affected by a decision may struggle to provide an entirely independent perspective.


This is one of the reasons I’ve become increasingly interested in executive coaching. Not because a coach necessarily knows what the right decision is. In most cases, they don’t, but because having someone who can listen, ask difficult questions and challenge your thinking without having a personal stake in the outcome can be enormously valuable.


Sometimes the most useful question isn’t, “What should I do?” It’s, “Why do I believe this is what I should do?” A good coaching conversation can expose assumptions we hadn’t recognised, fears we hadn’t acknowledged and alternatives we hadn’t properly considered. It doesn’t remove the responsibility of making the decision. It helps us become more deliberate about how we make it.


Learning to live with uncertainty

Perhaps the hardest lesson I’ve learned about leadership is that sometimes you never discover whether you made the right decision. There is no definitive answer. The alternative course of action remains unexplored. The future unfolds in ways nobody could have predicted. People move on, circumstances change, and the opportunity to compare outcomes disappears. We are left with the knowledge that we made a choice, but not necessarily with the reassurance that it was the best one.


I think becoming comfortable with that uncertainty is an important part of becoming a mature leader. It doesn’t mean becoming indifferent to consequences or abandoning the pursuit of good judgement. Quite the opposite. It means taking the decision-making process seriously precisely because we cannot guarantee the outcome.


We gather the best evidence available. We listen to people who disagree with us. We challenge our assumptions. We consider the consequences for those affected. We examine whether our decision is consistent with our values. Then, at some point, we decide. We take responsibility for what happens next, remain willing to change course when new information emerges, and resist the temptation to rewrite history when things don’t turn out as expected.


I’ve spent much of my professional life in environments where making decisions is an essential part of the job. Yet I increasingly think that good leadership is less about having the answers and more about developing the judgement to act when the answers are incomplete.


Perhaps the real measure of leadership isn’t whether we always make the right decisions. It’s whether we make thoughtful, principled decisions using the best information available, take responsibility for the consequences, and remain willing to learn.


What has been the most difficult decision you’ve faced as a leader? Looking back, do you know whether you made the right choice?


I explore the challenges of leadership, decision-making and executive resilience through my work with Blackridge Leadership.

Comments


bottom of page